Review: Sister Citizen, Melissa Harris-Perry

I am interested in the ways people are affected by representations of race, gender, sexuality, etc., in the media. It seems like Oscar Wilde was right all along: Life reflects art. If you watch gay people on TV you are more likely to want them to get married. And Melissa Harris-Perry is a feminist whose writing and thinking I like quite a bit. So when she writes a book about representations of black women in American culture, I’m obviously there.

Sister Citizen: Shame, Stereotypes, and Black Women in America (affiliate links: Amazon, B&N, Book Depository) is about the stereotypes that exist in American society about black women, and the ways that black women counteract those stereotypes, and the toll that counteracting the stereotypes can take. (See? It’s right in my wheelhouse!)

Harris-Perry begins by taking on the three classic stereotypical representations of black women: Jezebel (hypersexualized black woman), Mammy (docile, maternal black woman who serves white interests), and Sapphire (angry black woman). She talks about how these images have been used in the past to discredit and silence and generally make life crappy for black women. These are stereotypes that trivialize or deny the truths of black women’s lives: call a black woman angry and you make her an instant caricature with decades-old resonance. Her anger ceases to be a problem worth addressing (a response to injustice, to abuse, to poverty) and becomes a punchline instead.

The analysis of these stereotypes was good, though fairly basic and familiar (because I am familiar with Melissa Harris-Perry). For me, the book shines the most in the second part, which deals with disaster and with strength. Harris-Perry draws on a range of surveys over the past twenty years to discuss the ways that society perceives black women in times of disaster. Belief in a just universe tends to make people blame disaster victims for their own misfortunes, an effect that tends to be particularly strongĀ  when the victims are black women. (Cf Hurricane Katrina.)

Harris-Perry is fantastic when she talks about the stereotype of the strong black woman — this one a stereotype that often holds an important place in black women’s self-images (as well as the self-images of black communities). As much pride and comfort as this image can carry, it also inclines women who hold it about themselves to be less willing to seek out help, and thus more depressed and isolated than they would otherwise be.

If you’re interested in representation and its influences, I recommend Sister Citizen. It’s well-written and carefully researched, if at times a little basic, and Harris-Perry is good about pointing out the limitations as well as the strengths of the studies she cites. Melissa Harris-Perry is one of my favorite feminists working today: invariably thoughtful and interesting!

American/British cover
American/British cover

Cover report: No separate British cover. No winner. I do like this cover quite a bit, however. Well-done, cover design people.

  • http://rhapsodyinbooks.wordpress.com rhapsodyinbooks

    I sort of get depressed over books like this. as in: when will things change!!!

    • Gin Jenny

      Me too! Me too. But it’s still interesting.

  • http://ofbooks.org Alice

    Very interesting, I don’t know nearly enough about the representation of black women so I’ll be buying this come payday! Time to educate myself.

    • Gin Jenny

      Do! You can’t do better than Melissa Harris-Perry — she’s very eloquent, and she’s also cautious about drawing broad conclusions from limited data. So it’s great.

  • http://twitter.com/MumsyNancy NWK (@MumsyNancy)

    This sounds amazing. I thought about this constantly when I worked with black adolescent girls – it is maddening to read about, but when you actually see it happening every day to kids you care about – it’s like seeing them being stuck into boxes and then watching the boxes get sledge-hammered.

    • Gin Jenny

      It was good. Are you familiar with Melissa Harris-Perry? She’s good, I think you’d like her.

  • http://www.tbr313.blogspot.com Lisa

    She is also one of my favorites – I’ll be looking for this book. Most of what I’ve read has dealt with African American women in the 19th century (when the same three stereotypes of course were predominant). and I need to read beyond that.

    • Gin Jenny

      Oo, what have you read about that? That sounds really interesting too!

  • http://www.readingonarainyday.com/ Athira

    Ooh, I like the sound of this one! I’m very fascinated by how media can shape people’s opinions and how you can make and break cases on media. I will have to look for this one.

    • Gin Jenny

      I am too! Reading this reminded me how much I enjoy media criticism.

  • Jenny

    I don’t know this author, but not only does this sound great, it sounds like something I should have for my library. Wait…I do! It’s an e-book. Sounds like Yet Another Book I Will Read Because Of Other Jenny.

    • Gin Jenny

      Yes! Ebooks! Ebooks are great! They make my life so much easier and happier.

  • http://juliaem.wordpress.com Julia

    Adding to my TBR list. Also, I find it very upsetting that LOL My Thesis doesn’t link back to the theses in question. I want to read them too…

    • Gin Jenny

      Me too! Me too! A few of them do, but not nearly enough.

  • http://twitter.com/anbolynp Anbolyn Potter (@anbolynp)

    I think black women are one of the most misunderstood groups of people in our society and I think it would be very enlightening to read more about their reality. I really don’t read much non-fiction, but this sounds very good and as an aunt to four biracial nieces it’s probably something I should keep in mind.

    • Gin Jenny

      I’ve been reading more nonfiction over the last few years, but yeah, I still do a ratio of probably three fiction to one nonfiction (if that low).

  • http://gravatar.com/litlove litlove

    Oh I love books that dig into issues around representation. This is something I feel I know so little about. Definitely the sort of book I should look out for.

  • aartichapati

    This sounds like a book I’d find very valuable as well. I can imagine how exhausting it must be to fight against the stereotypes people hold of you. I just saw The Butler last night, and it really just reiterated how much history there is behind these stereotypes. It’s not like I wasn’t aware of it before, but one can become complacent sometimes, and it’s important to remind yourself and inform yourself.

  • http://gravatar.com/sarahsaysread Sarah Says Read

    This sounds really interesting! While I read about racism in general, I never read about racism specifically towards black women. I’ll keep an eye out for this.